Tuesday, January 18, 2011

Driving the Kahr - a Review of the PM40


There are few times I don't carry (I'll take my chances in the shower, I could always clobber them with the Irish Spring ). There are weapons I carry when where I'm going warrants some heavy iron, and then there are the "back up gun" days. When I'm comfortable with something smaller, lighter, that will conceal a little easier. A gun that's reliable,accurate and will preferably chamber a duty-caliber round. I love my Sig, S and W's and the XD's but I was wanting something a little bigger in caliber, while still remaining decently concealable.

Enter the Kahr PM40. It's ultra-compact without being wimpy, double action only (DAO), chambered in .40 S&W. For a long time my BUG was a S&W J Frame, (Speer GDHP 135gr +p) but when a friend bought one of these I had to try it, and liked it well enough to add to the "want to buy" list, though the S & W will always have first place in my heart.

When the first Kahr pistols appeared on the market in 1994 they were constructed entirely of carbon steel. The Kahr models such as the K9 were praised as being well-made and solidly constructed, but criticized for their excessive weight. Excess weight is a disadvantage in any weapon intended for concealed carry. Kahr took this in mind in refining the line, introducing pistols which were physically smaller, as well as a line of polymer framed models. The PM series combined both these approaches, introducing polymer framed pistols that were also the smallest Kahr models ever produced


This one came with a stainless steel slide, barrel, and trigger. The stainless slide is finished in a blackened matte that almost borders on satin. With the many stainless components corrosion or pitting on warm, sweaty days won't be too much of a problem. It does sport a somewhat heavy spring so when you rack the slide you will need to grip it and rip it.

With an empty magazine it's only about 17 ounces and is less than an inch thick. It shoots a lot like a Glock 27 but it’s even smaller and thinner. I put a S&W 642 on top for a size comparison and the PM40 is smaller than the J frame, (and thinner when you take the cylinder and grips on the J frame into consideration).

Caliber? It’s a 40 S&W! Of course, there will be lots of debate as to what is the best ammo for it, though the Federal HST in .40 is quite the potent round, solid in a compact gun.

Is this a fun gun to shoot? Well, it put holes exactly where I wanted on paper. That in and of itself is fun anytime, but I'd have to say not for use all afternoon long with this as a target gun. Give me my Sig or the 1911 or the new XDM, but it's fun enough to keep proficient in case

There is no external safety, the gun relying rather on that long trigger pull (think revolver). In an adrenalin situation, the fine motor skills are the first thing to go. Simplified controls are a positive attribute in my opinion and contribute to a desirable package for concealment use.

The trigger pull, though long, is silky smooth without being insubstantially light, but there's the matter of recoil. A little more than I imagined but quite manageable, if you're not going to shoot 100 rounds at a time through it. It's a light pistol with a high pressure cartridge, you're going to have recoil.


But the Kahr ergonomics are excellent and it's quite controllable. I'd say it was closest to the .38 special J-frame with heavy +P loads. If you're going to fire off a whole box of ammo, the web of your hand is going to smart. But that's not why I have it. It's lightweight, it's powerful, and it's small. It is also a gun you want to practice with. Like the .45 caliber variant it can have some gun handling challenges in rapid fire due to the heavier recoil and resulting muzzle rise, the same as about any small and light large bore pistol. Not an issue for an experienced shooter who practices.

Size Matters. About 5 and a half inches long and 4 inches high, it will fit under most of my shirts without obvious bulk. Kahr has done a bang up job in making a weapon that will fit perfectly in my delicate but large hand. If you've got, not big, but huge hands, this might not work, but this is for concealed right? Small concealed. If you have Shrek sized hands and want something that fits it perfectly you'd best look at a full-framed pistol. It's solid, and if you need to point it at someone, the look of it alone will get their attention more than that slim little Kel Tec.


The compact size of this piece makes it an excellent choice for carrying. It comes with two stainless magazines, one 5 rounder that is flush with the mag well and one 6 rounder that sticks out below the mag well with a place for your pinky to grip.

But if you try it and the grip just isn't going to work, even considering why you are carrying it, you might look elsewhere. This is not a gun you can mess around with your grip with. "Firm and relaxed" need not apply. You need to grip this gun like a snake with PMS. Hold On. After your first shot, when you realize that the recoil you expect is much more pleasant than something light weight in the .44 Magnum category (ow, ow ow) you might be inclined to smile and relax just a little. Don't. Hold on tight. You'll be surprised how well you can shoot right off the bat with a firm grip. It's also quite accurate, with a firm hand.

Straight out of the box I shot this target with my first magazine at about 30 feet. I bent my support hand a little more on the next round, but I was pleased. My range buddies didn't snicker at me either.

The only problem I had with it was when the gun was new. I place a loaded mag in the weapon and pulled the slide manually back and let it go. It did not go all the way into battery. I then went from slide locked back position and used the thumb release to chamber a round, and perfect! I think that was more a one time, being new thing, as after a few rounds through it it worked great, no misfeeds, misfires or jams. The manufacturer states that the gun is not to be considered to be reliable (aka broken in) until at least 250 rounds have been run through it, and I agree though 500 rounds was more like it. I did not have that problem again.

The sights? Bar-dot like my Sig. Easier to pick up than 3 dot in my opinion.


My only complaint is that slide release. The pistol is so small, and the release so sharp, I ended up away with painful gouges on my shooting hand thumb until I adjusted my grip a bit away from the frame. I don't know if it's enough that I'd want to take a file to those edges though.

As for price, well they are a tad expensive. They run between $660 and $700 for the full stainless one depending on where you get it. That's a lot of cash in today's economy for a back up gun and you could buy a couple of Bersa's for that amount. But you are paying for life long quality and although quite a few have been sold in the local gun stores you rarely see them come back in the used guns.

All in all, it's a super small, light, high quality, big caliber pistol that you can depend on. There are other guns out there in that category but this is one that I like. An excellent piece. . . . to support or reinforce.

26 comments:

maddmedic said...

CW9 here. Love it. Was at Bill's Gun Shop yesterday and they had a used CW 45 for under 400 bucks. I had to leave rapidly...no funds available!! Dang! Have looked at the PMs and certainly have thought about trading....
Very happy with my Kahr...

Tango Juliet said...

This isn't the first time I've read a kick against the sharp edged slide stop of the Kahr. Don't know why they continue to let 'em out the door thataway.

ASM826 said...

I thought the point of a polymer gun was for shower carry. Sort of a "gun on a rope".

ViolentIndifference said...

I was cruising right along enjoying a great review until I got to "You need to grip this gun like a snake with PMS." and I had to laugh out loud.

WV: earing (What are the odds of that?)

evaneaston said...

Good review. I carry an MK9. It's the all steel version of the PM9. So virtually identical in size except slightly wider in the grip and obviously heaver.

Everyone I know who has actually shot their little Kahr knows that the slide release lever is sharp from the factory. I learned the hard way shooting about 450 rounds through it one day at a holster class. If you plan on practicing with it, it's definitely worth knocking the edges down on that lever.

And if the grip is just a smidgen too small or the gun gets loose from sweaty hands, there are some moleskin-like grip wraps (one's called Agrip) that are very thin so they don't change the grip dimensions more than a fraction of a millimeter. They cover up the heavily checkered grip with a soft material that seems to allow some to hold onto the gun better.

Boy are these things easy to conceal. Easy to shoot really well? Not so much. But they make great little carry guns.

Ed Foster said...

Oohhh! Me want! Especially in .45. If you can't have a longer barrel for better expansion ratio, you have to go sideways and screw out a bigger hole to cut down on the flashbang and speed loss.

Maybe someday when I grow up, the boss will let me play with designing something like that. Right now he wants a 3 inch 1911 with an Officer's length frame.

Trying to fit a spring inside a bobtail mainspring housing that short makes alcoholism look inviting. Some ideas don't scale as easily as you would think. If I dump the grip safety it becomes easy, but if there's anything you need a grip safety on, it's a bitty .45 with a short handle.

Still, it beats assistant manager at McDonalds.

I wonder if the answer to a small pistol in a serious caliber isn't to abandon the Browning type slide entirely and go to a short recoil functioned rotating bolt with cycle mass in an Uzi style shroud around the barrel?

Let's see. I'm sitting on top of 50,000 M-16 bolts, all of which fit 9mm ammo quite nicely. They also have a cam slot in them.

A simple aluminum frame, maybe a Kahr magazine, and I'm in charge for a week, while the powers that be are out at the SHOT Show. I smell some late nights approaching.

Ma'am, thank you once again for being my muse. It really does sound as if you're getting better at a splendid rate, something all of your friends to rejoice in.

And now, back to screwing guns together. A tough job, but....

D.W. said...

I've got the K9, and can attest to the fact that the sucker is heavy. However it is so reliable, and fits my hand so perfectly, that the extra weight doesn't bother me. I just keep it in the nightstand instead of carrying it. If I run out of ammo I can always use it as a tiny steel club.

YeOldFurt said...

I do NOT have "Shrek-sized" hands, the Colt New Services just fit right for me. Everything else seems a tad on the small side.
Glad you're doing better and able to get out and about now.
The Kahr is such a "cute" little gun and I'm glad they've added a little bite to it.
YeOldFurt

Arthur said...

Is the barrel actually stainless?

The one in my Kahr P380 appears to be nickel plated. The exterior stays rust free, but the bore will get rust spots in it if I'm not diligent about keeping the pocket fuzz out of it.

JPG said...

Outstanding review, Bridg. This may be the most objective look at a handgun I've read. You tell the good stuff, but include what might be drawbacks for some users.

I've owned only one .40 S&W, a Hi Power, and it was pretty demanding of PERFECT handloads. Had I stuck with factory ammo, I think all would have been well. It was just not much "fun" to shoot. For duty use, it was a BUNCH heavier than my .45 Commander, so I eventually swapped it off.

I had a Kahr P9 for a time. It was a pleasure to shoot but was just a tad large for pants pocket carry. You have me musing that a PM40 might be the sidearm I need for everyday carry. I love my aluminum frame .38s, but there have been times when a light, flat, .40-shooter would have been a comfort . . .

Some of us ol' dawgs aren't too proud to admit that we can learn stuff from you youngsters.

TJIC said...

> I thought the point of a polymer gun was for shower carry. Sort of a "gun on a rope".

"Yeah, I dropped the soap...what are you going to do about it?"

Six said...

Thanks for the review Brigid. I'm considering a new CCW gun. I've been looking at the nines, especially the new Sig P290 but after reading this I'll take a long look at this pistol.

drjim said...

Nice review. I'm not in the position to need a firearm like that, but it sounds pretty impressive.
The last time I carried a BUG was for a training class, and I borrowed a little S&W 340PD in 357.
The first time we had to "Transition to Backup" and fire, I thought I broke my wrist!
I got it in the 9-ring, though!

dantesfiringrange said...

"This isn't the first time I've read a kick against the sharp edged slide stop of the Kahr. Don't know why they continue to let 'em out the door thataway."

I don't understand why they don't come out with an "Elite" version of the PMs that is all dehorned and snazzyfied like the MK Elite's. I guess they are trying to keep the price point but on a gun that the slide stop is the recommended way to load fresh mags, it seems kinda foolish.

My MK9 Elite 2000 has a nice rounded slide release and works like a charm without cutting up the thumb. I ended up finding it cheaper since it was back stock in a Show Dealer's inventory. It's been my primary gun for 5 years now. Heavy as a dark sin held nervously in the soul for it's size, but in a good holster, it bides well on my hip with only a few tugs per day to get the belt back to trim.

The slide and spring are very sensitive to any "riding" and will tend to fail to go into battery if you do that. I learned the "Slingshot" method and it hasn't been an issue since then. I don't like to use the slide release since some of the guns I have don't have it.

I did have to get Kahr to put a new slide and barrel on it when the extractor answered a call from the angels and gave up the ghost. Customer service was responsive and I had them put some night sights on for me while it was back in MA visiting relatives.

All in all, I've been very pleased with Kahr and when I grow up, (or down, as it's a present for when I hit my goal weight) I'm looking at the P45. The PM may just be too small for .45 ACP?

Bubblehead Les. said...

Don't carry in the Shower? I should say not! That's why a Stainless J-Frame w/ Rubber Grips should be in a drawer by the sink (if there are no small children in the home, of course).

MaineMapleDave said...

"grip...like a snake with PMS."

I had to take a post-laugh-breather after that one!!!

Is there a greatest hits (so to speak) of Brigid-isms?

Old NFO said...

PM9 here, FYI, it takes at least 200 rounds to break it in, and yes, practice IS required! But you will enjoy it!

Crawler said...

My son purchased a new stainless MK40 a few years ago. At the time, he really wanted the PM40 but the gun shop had sold out of them.

A year or so ago he stumbled across a new black PM40 with night sights and he took it home. He already had the holsters for it, ammo and another added plus he figured was the magazines are the exactly the same for both pistols.

He swears by those two Kahrs for concealed carry.

I’ve shot both of his and I wholeheartedly agree with your review.

Crawler said...

I knew I was saving those last two bottled Guinness Extra Stout 12-ounce for a reason!

I’ll be raising a glass shortly to you and the good news.

Carry on ma’am…

2yellowdogs said...

I got my CW9 a few months ago and other than being a little larger, your review comports well with my experience.

I just love that buttery trigger. Yes, it's a long pull, but that's what you want in a DAO, no-safety gun. To me, it's very much like a good revolver trigger.

Very happy with the gun.

Keads said...

Now see that is what makes you a writer! I did a review on a gun and after reading your review I think I was pretty much a Neanderthal!

Here is a synopsis of my review compared to yours: "Ugh, puts bullets downrange, good."

Bravo on the Kahr, but I must ask do you have one of the dresses from the Kahr "Thin is in" ad campaigns?

Cond0010 said...

I just had an intruder in one of my buildings yesterday.

This item would have been some nice insurance.

ViolentIndifference said...

----
Bravo on the Kahr, but I must ask do you have one of the dresses from the Kahr "Thin is in" ad campaigns?
----

Not likely. Brigid is a woman, not a stick.

Keads said...

@VI- I concur, but had to ask!

Keads said...

Well, I would much rather view a woman in a tight fitting dress regardless if they were a "bag of antlers" or not.

I prefer the non antler profile. I am possessed with the correct Y Chromosome to note such females.

Hey a guy can dream right?

I brought that up because I do have a disconnect with the "Booth Babes" (car, gun, industrial equipment, Dillon calenders, etc.)

The thing about the Kahr ads is they promote the thin firearm and show a thin model in a dress that could never conceal it.

Brighid said...

I stumbled on your blog awhile back and have truly enjoyed reading it. Looking for your input/expertise on what type of gun I should get for my personal protection. I know next to nothing about handguns, have shot my share of rifles, & shotguns, been a while, limited funds, and grandkids around, travel around the west on my own in the back of beyond. Any recommendations would be great.
cowcamp@frontier.com