Fighting for something. We fight for status, position. For tenure and safety. Some people take it to the next level with physical fighting skills, not just cerebral ones. The thought of physical threats is never a pleasant one. Some people would just as soon close the blinds and pretend the danger does not exist. But you only have to look at a few law enforcement blotters and missing persons reports to get you thinking about the dangers that women carry with them, the dangers that men bear just by walking on a predator's turf. This is a long post, and one I hope you will read, especially my female readers.
A former neighbor, a young Dr. in her late 20's was a black belt and an instructor at a local studio. Before she had a serious boyfriend, we'd sit out on one of our decks with a cold beer and compare scars. I taught her how to cook, (which helped with that whole boyfriend issue I hope) and she taught me some advanced karate, to enhance my very amateur skill level and some of the philosophy for that mind set.
I earned the kind of belt that, definitely wasn't black, but it kept my shirt from falling off. Some of my team, and friends, are former special ops. My squirrel partner is also black belt. When I was hanging around one of them one day, I asked him to test me on my defensive skills against someone determined to hurt me, to see how badly my skills had degraded with age and a promotion which meant more "desk" than "field". I trust him, this is my partner, so I figured I might learn something. Size wise, he was taller than I and 205 pounds of muscle to my 5' 8" and (mumble mumble) pounds. Not a tremendous size difference, right? Wrong.

A simulated weapon (snack sized Rice Crispy Treat) went into my simulated holster ( sticking out of my side pant pocket) to see how fast I could "draw" if that was more prudent than fighting back. This was NOT an exercise of my gun skills, simply my reaction/defensive skill degradation after too much desk time. If you're going to do this with real weapons folks, train with the pros.
We started up close and a few feet apart, strangers that met on say, a jogging path. In this case I played "blissfully unaware" of his intent and had my hand on something other than near my "holster". When he sprung, he was on me before I could even get my hand to my pocket. In a nanosecond he had one hand on my chin/mouth area and other grasping my head, and I got a very delicate but firm little twisting movement, and a "surprise, I just rent your vertebrae, you're on the floor dying". It didn't hurt me at all, but I definitely felt the pressure and incredible strength behind those hands and knew that he could have done it, easily. I hadn't even touched the rice crispy yet. All Righty Now. Let's try something else.
Then we did the "come up from behind" scenario. (no way was this man getting near my nasion or my philtrum). There I am happily" walking along that "walking trail" and I got a knee knee against the back of my knee. I go forward and the simulated Gerber Mark II (a finger) had stabbed into the right side of my neck and then forward (at which point I started laughing as it tickled.). Again. Dead. I still was open mouthed as how quickly he closed the distance.
So much for handling the surprise attack at close range. We did another one where I might have a chance. I went about my business around the rooms, crispy treat in the "holster", covered up with "the house is 65 degrees outwear" typical concealed. It was a bulky sweater type jacket with overly long sleeves. He got past me and about nine feet downwind and then made his move. I got the .45 acp rice crispy treat out before he got to me (how do you move that fast?). Had that "weapon" been in a purse or underneath a large, thick coat I would have been toast again. But one problem arose. In the second or two while I fumbled for the trigger ( for there is none on the crispy treat) he had my arm to my right, and then applied a movement to my arm, surprise, I had a simulated broken elbow and was NOT going to be able to shoot with that arm. It didn't hurt me at all, intent not pressure, but I was glad for a moment that I can eat Rice Crispy Treats left handed.
The good news, you're likely not going to be up against someone trained in those types of maneuvers. You're not ALWAYS going to be wearing a bulky garment sweater with long sleeves. Your weapon will have a trigger, not blue packaging material. Your attacker may be buff but he is as likely to be as out of shape as the average Joe. But, as well, they might be 19 and 210 pounds of youth and muscle and you might be 5 foot nothing and 100 pounds. The thing is YOU CAN NEVER ASSUME. You MUST practice, keeping those hard earned skills up and you must be aware of what your situation is so that your weapon is easy to access, and you are ready.
I learned one thing, my limited martial arts training does me little good if I don't keep up with it. And if I don't stay focused to a threat and where my hand is when that threat is around and what my "outs" are, I'm only going to come out ahead if my attacker is a yard gnome or a rapist wheeling his oxygen canister.
It was an eye opener. Shooting a 1 inch group at a stationary paper target isn't going to help me if I haven't practiced in six months, in varying conditions using my non dominant hand as well.
Shoot when it's hot, when it's freezing, with gloves and with cold, cold hands. Draw and shoot from the holster (check with your range as to rules on such practice), draw and shoot from low ready.

I wasn't surprised when Caleb joined me at the range that freezing day and Tam is often out in all conditions. There's a reason those two are such skilled shooters.

But, practice or not, a gun won't help you if you're weighed down by an overly large, bulky coat or too many shopping bags, etc. Having some basic shooting skills for the attacker isn't going to help you if he has training on how to take my gun and you don't. And nothing is going to help you if you let your guard down and don't stay on alert to behavior around you. Situational awareness is everything. And even if you think you are big and strong, as a female, remember, mass is everything. A guy that outweighs you by even just 20 or 30 pounds of muscle (about 10% more than your muscle mass) can easily take you down.
I learned a lot of things with this, the most important being that although I risk having someone take it from me, I risk far more by not carrying a weapon . For I'm too aware of the world that is out there in the shadows. It's NOT a safe place, and it won't be by ignoring it. Being in a small town may reduce the odds but it doesn't protect you.
You may go the rest of your life and not meet up with evil, someone bent on hurting you or killing you. If you don't, what have you lost by this mindset? Nothing. Not your innocent belief in all that is good. I lost that at least 3 elections ago.
But if you do meet up with evil, and you are not prepared, you will have lost something. For, if you live, you will be looking back, to that parking lot at the bank or library or grocery, back to the untainted time and smell and taste of when you HAD that choice, of where you walked and what people you let into your space, when the denial process won out over the actuality of human nature. Back before you were a victim. And you will ask yourself, over and over again, in long, lonely silences at night, when you've lost a part of yourself you will never get back. WHY didn't I see the signs? Why didn't I take action before it was too late?
I've been a volunteer at a family violence center for a few years. It's not necessarily a pleasant task at times, but one that needs to be done, by those that care or who have seen it firsthand. That type of violence doesn't just happen to the poor, the uneducated the needy. We see women of all walks of life in there that just share one thing in common, that they have been scared for so long that they just get used to being that way. Sometimes you'd just find them in their room in the warm and cozy shelter home, in the dark. You can feel people in a dark room. You don't need to see them. Sometimes they're just asleep, catching up on that precious commodity, sleep where you know someone who cares is watching over your safety.
They don't sleep well, for years, violence going to bed with them each night, often drunk, normally angry. They'd lay there in the bed, trying not to move, trying to make themselves smaller and smaller so not to be noticed. Trying not to breathe for when they breathed they could hear them, hear that dark mass of anger sizing them up for what is only one persons idea of fun or a fight. They could feel the blood in their veins, the little involuntary twitch at the corner of their eye as they're shut tighter and tighter as if by doing so you will not see what you know is coming. It takes a long time to sleep well after that.
So, there in the safety of the shelter, if their bedroom door was not blocked you'd just knock and say a soft hello and and tell them you'd wait outside. They'd sit there in the dark of their ruined life, sometimes with a chair propped up against the door, afraid that even in this refuge they would be found. But soon they would come out, into the light, amazed that with tools and training, they could learn to live a life of comparative inviolation.

Violence can wear the hand of a family member, but we deal with that, with what we can. But it also shops with us, drives with us, peering at us from a van in the shopping center parking lot, or from over their shoulder as they bend to tie their shoe as you jog on past, down that blind canyon of trees from which you will not return.
A few years ago, there was a talented young woman who was kidnapped by someone she struck up a conversation with her in a national forest, a kindly looking older guy who then went on to terrorize her and kill her. She was young and very strong. She was a Black Belt. It was a sobering revelation.
Martial Arts is a wonderful tool, but it's naive to think that is a representation of street self defence, in that you obviously aren't going to execute pre-planned patterns of memorized movements against an attacker. And if you learn it you must keep up the practice and skills. It's not just a force. It's a tool, a habit pattern of strength. It's a pattern of practice. It is is a mind set. The teachers will teach more then the moves. They teach you mental discipline. Some of the instruction to me at first seemed silly, balancing something on my outstretched hands, etc, but that was to teach me humility, not so that I would consider myself a lesser form, but so myself, or the other male students, would not feel the need to "prove" ourselves. Just because you can kick some one's butt doesn't mean you're better OR bulletproof. I've spent many a afternoon compiling what remained of those that thought they were bullet proof.
You need to be proficient and you need to anticipate. Anticipate the unexpected. I also personally think you need to have a plan "b" when just blocks or jabs are not going to deter what's staring you in the face.I am glad I took the training I did. But what I got out of it was the knowledge that it was not to turn me into Chuck Norris, but it designed specifically to get rapid, combat-useful responses built into my reflexes. The constant motions and endless repetition of the same movements become incorporated into my muscle memory, there waiting to be used instantly in a reaction, completely or nearly completely without specific conscious direction. THAT is an invaluable tool whether you carry a concealed weapon or not.
But for someone my size and gender, that may not be enough to help me me if I have an arm full of groceries,my gun in my purse, and a guy is walking towards me with a weapon I may or may not be aware of. Just something to think about.
Your choices for protection are yours. I won't preach to you here in this post on why you should carry, I will only tell you why I do. My family is all, male and female alike, law enforcement, defense or military. Strong people of strong stuff. Some of that rubbed off. But I will tell you that there is no mind set, no background that will protect you if you do not look, be aware of your surroundings, and practice.
Here are some basics:Listen: dump that MP3 player or phone. Not only will it help alert you to Mr. Mugger it will alert you to Mr. Oncoming Bus.
Look. Look up, look at people. REALLY look at people. Stand up straight and look them in the eye. Criminals are predators and they will normally exhibit predatory behavior in preparing to attack. They will look at their intended victim far more and for longer periods of time than social norms. They will move when the prey moves. They will stop and look around for witnesses. They may make more than one pass by you, be it walking or jogging to see how you react or get a layout of how they will strike. They will move with you, around you. Think sharks with shoes on.
When I've counseled women who have lived with violence, without exception they saw the behavior early on. Control. Restricting their movements, reading their mail or monitoring their phone calls. Possession Anger. They know now how to see those signs and run. Do you know the signs out in public that you are being targeted by a stranger?
Stay with people. Under no circumstances let yourself be taken somewhere, for where you are going has a name. It's called the "secondary crime scene", where your worst nightmare will enter your soul. Do NOT get in a vehicle, do NOT walk around the building into the alley, stay where others will see you, if he doesn't have a gun or flat edged weapon, drop to the ground. Let him PICK your dead weight off of the ground, and if he tries, fight like hell. If he says "don't scream or I'll kill you", he's probably going to kill you anyway, don't go out quietly. He doesn't want to get caught. He LIKES this. Run, crawl out a window, go to lights and others. Make noise. If you are in a car and being followed do NOT drive home, drive to your nearest fire station (staffed 24 hours) or police station (though they may not be open 24 in 7 in all jurisdictions) and start honking your horn. DO NOT get out of your vehicle until the threat is removed.

If he's a viable threat, put a hole in him. Go on, ruin HIS day.
Block. Barriers are good. doors, windows, STAY IN YOUR CAR. Put the muzzle of a .45 between you and his hands. The more likely he is to be discovered or injured the less likely he will be to continue.

Train: Whatever you are comfortable with to protect yourself be it physical conditioning and maneuvers or the use of a firearm by the law abiding, practice, learn, watch those with experience, learn from professionals. It isn't about you on film with your latest gear. It's about staying alive. What you are looking for is "Practiced Proficiency” where the draw and point of the weapon to kill becomes second nature.
Use your strongest weapons against their weakest targets. Practice this regularly. If you are female and are going to learn martial arts, don't take 4 lessons in "rape prevention" and call it a day. There are many forms. Don't go to the first place that has a fancy store front and sign up. Talk to a master, talk to others who study that discipline. If you are going to get training to use a gun, get proper training, full spectrum training to include retention techniques. As competent retention techniques wander into the realm of unarmed hand to hand, you will find any martial arts muscle memory skills may assist you. (but only if you practice!)
There will be a lot of discussion on this post, pros and cons. All I know is what I am comfortable with, given my age, training, size and gender. I will watch and I will listen, but to me the choice for self defense is obvious. A gun in the hands of a proficient user, hanging on that belt that just keeps my pants up.
There are enough victims in this world. I don't wish to add to their numbers.
37 comments:
I wish that every single person alive would & could take this post to heart. That can't happen, for obvious reasons.
But my wife and daughters can and will. Beyond that, I can only encourage. And with words like yours, the job is much, much easier.
Thank you.
Rice Krispies?!?!? A training aid?!? Seriously?? Nothing simulates a Glock better than a Twinkie! (Little known fact: Tennifer is derived from Twinkie squeezins.)
It is truly stunning to learn just how quickly an aggressor can close the gap. Situational awareness beats a quick draw everytime.)
Can you somehow put this post on 'net somehow with bright flashing neon signs?? Good stuff Brigid!!!!
Good advice as I'm having my 16 year old gal read this... it is an ongoing topic her father keeps bringing up before she's out of the nest...
I see so many co-eds where I teach blindly walking around with earbuds blocking their hearing and their eyes firming fixed on their tapping thumbs...
Dann in Ohio
You have spoken volumes with this post. Great words that anyone man or woman should heed.
I routinely tell students that just because they spend 8 hours in the classroom with me and passed a live fire qualification that exceeds State requirements, they are just beginning.
One of the big issues I have is that just because they have a CCH permit and have a pistol on them, some think that alone in and of itself is a Talisman that will ward off evil. That is wrong and a disservice to my students if they leave thinking that.
As you point out that is a recipe for disaster. I tell my students that the Firearm is truly the last resort, you have exhausted all other options.
Not every problem is a gun problem. If you do your homework, maintain awareness of your surroundings and give up the ingrained politeness we were all taught (if required), this can do much as you point out.
I always say to call out a perceived threat. That is even now becoming more problematic. Saying "Can I help you" to let them know you see them and are aware is inviting them closer to you. Now it is simply "STOP"!
I am not a large guy. My physical skills are not that impressive. The skills I do try to work on are unarmed tactics to at least get to presentation so I can use the tool if need be.
Then as you say you must accurately operate the machine in a variety of conditions. The square range can instill many bad habits.
Whoops! Sorry to bore your readers with my pedestrian ramblings!
Oh, I am going to SO steal that tux shirt shot as soon as I can find my Colt SAA cufflinks! Hope you don't mind.
Thank you for such wise reminders, for everyone not just women.
Make up your mind to have a survival attitude no matter what comes along. Trust all instincts, if it seems "odd" - it is, move away immediately.
Be prepared, be aware, but keep on living life.
All great points! And a TRUE reality check...Thanks for posting this!
Thanks, Brigid! EVERYONE needs to read this, women, men, professionals, civilians...
Skills degrade, that's why they're called skills.
Practice. We revert to what we're trained to do. IF we keep practiced!
Must. Shoot. More. I know I'm not good enough with my gun! The online movie Just Yell Fire is a good self defense overview for women, especially. Just google it, and you'll find it pretty easily.
BK - I sometimes go months with work and taking care of my Dad and the family leave that involves.
If you're ever up this way, I would be proud to have you join Tam, Roberta, Midwest Chick and myself for a shoot.
I'm going to Colorado tomorrow to see my daughter, there WILL be some range time involved.
Thanks for the reminder! Need to dust off the punching/kicking target in the basement.
Tae Kwon Do lessons went bye-bye a while after my last teacher had a heart attack, but that should not prevent me from practicing. (TKD Masters of 4th degree or higher are generally >40 or 50 unless they started training when they were 5, hence the heart attack.) Unfortunately, a concealable handgun is just not in the budget at the moment.
Most excellent post. SOmewhere out there, a gun or women's magazine or two is missing out on some article gold. Seriously.
Great post. I wish everyone would pay attention to the surroundings. My granddaughters text all the time, head down, walking along. Sure, with me around, they can probably get by with it, but it's a bad habit to cultivate.
This is a good reminder, Brigid.
Being that I have walked to work during off hours (~11pm), this kind of thing is commonly on my mind.
Though I am big enough (and male) so that in am not on the menu for certain kinds of predators, I have had a few random encounters in the last decade and a half doing this whole night thing.
Since guns are the 'nuclear weapons' of the personal encounter (no turning back once drawn - and with permanent consequences), I've always thought of the layered defense being the best approach.
But what would those layers be? ... and how could you know which to use in the heat of the moment when falling into the kill-zone of the unknown and unidentified predator?
Obviously, I haven't sorted this out, though I do carry mace.
My nephew who is a deputy said that if an attacker with a knife is within 21 feet of him, he will shoot.
People can move very quickly.
I'm getting to the age that issues of age and being elderly are now important. How does an elderly person get martial arts training, lots of range time, etc.?
Great essay, thank you
B -
The Street Survival series that goes around country used to have a very sobering video regarding the distance that can be covered if someone was running towards you with an edged weapon, before you would recognize the threat and react.
From what I recall, 21 feet was minimal distance to accomplish shooting the attacker.
21 feet....
Gotta send this link to my daughter...
Thank you so much for posting, Brigid! I really admire you for your ability to use words wisely and beautifully.
I can't tell you enough how reading not just your blog, but the many others out there that I read about guns and self-defense has really influenced me in such a positive way.
I know too many people who think all that time spent preparing is a waste of time, for an "Unlikely event" or that the police will protect them :P
Seriously great post!
The training you described is useful in determining how far your danger circle should be based on how long it takes you to identify and react to a threat.
Based on my own age, girth and response time, my danger circle is about 150 yards. It makes being at Walmart challenging.
I have noticed here in Northern Virginia that the number of people attached to their Iphones and updating their facebook/myspace/email, lots and lots of people have no awareness of their surroundings any more. Total device focus, even while walking.
As an aside, if you are in the habit of looking for predators, you begin to resemble them. It can be awkward when to people who are practicing their awareness spot each other being aware and misidentify each other as predators. Oddly enough, thee are so few people doing this that the chances of two such people meeting is low.
Seems so simple to me...Get a gun and Get ready (practice).
Thanks Brigid. I'll be sharing this with Mrs Aggie and other close friends.
Gene WA5AC
Aggie, Class of '70
Brigid, thank you so much for posting this; I will be sharing it with my wife. Two years ago someone tried to kick in the door at the hotel we were staying in; Samara was astonished by my (fast to her, too slow to me) reaction time. No I did not feel funny buck naked except for my glasses and a .45. My mentor, a flight medic, 5th Dan Chayon Ryu, instructor who served 5 combat tours with the IDF regularly performs surprise assaults on me, as your colleague did for you, to keep me sharp. Now I just need more range time, more time in the do jang and formal training.
Outstanding, as usual, I will link this and direct my female readers to attend.
I have always said "I might be able to take on of them but no way two"!...now I'm thinking I can't even take one of them and that includes carrying. Sometimes when I am jogging in the middle of the desert all by myself with my little running pistol in my shorts pocket a cow will come out of the brush and scare the crap out of me...I didn't even see it! Then I always realize wake up!!...So much to think about!...that is the one thing I always preach to my nieces...DO NOT GET IN THE CAR no matter what.
Excellent, excellent post! I just sent it to my 20 yr old step-daughter to read. I am constantly telling her...put the damn phone down when walking out of a store, look up and around quit looking at your feet. LOOK LOOK LOOK Just being aware of your surroundings is a huge deterrent. Cell phones is the worse when it comes to self defense.
Girl. This could not have been written any better. Thank you for sharing!
Perfection! I wish I'd had something like this when I was a young punk. I did, at least, know enough to use the reflective surfaces in the city to look for watchers, followers.
I had a dream not long ago of being at home and bad guys coming through the door - my gun was in the living room, closer to them than me. That really changed my procedures at home.
I did want to mention for the older folks out there - get a cane, regardless of whether you need one. It may be all you have and a good sharp stick ala Newt: http://newtlivesayknives.com/WEAPONS_CANES-FIGHTING.htm is better than frail fists.
Required reading for my daughter. Period.
Thank you.
--AOA
An Ordinary American - welcome,and thank you.
I wrote a piece for Concealed Carry Magazine last year, along these lines, written as a mother, to a daughter.
We can't stress it enough to our children and loved ones.
This is depressing and infuriating.
Years ago, a friend of mine was bragging about how his 8yo daughter had obtained her black belt... in 3 months.
Zero to black belt in 3 months, going one day a week, for (I think it was) a 1 hour lesson.
The girl was all too happy to show all the neat things she had learned. Going through form after form as if it were a dance, it was impressive looking to say the least, but had little to do with fighting or defending herself. When I pointed this out to said friend he said "Why would I send my little girl somewhere to learn how to fight?" and acted like I was the one who was out of touch with reality.
I just shook my head...
s
I sent this to my daughter. She was asking about self defense training before a school-sponsored trip to London and Paris. It should help her evaluate the trainings/trainers.
An I found it worthwhile, too. ;-)
Thankfully, and yet sadly, I can sense an awful lot of dads sending this on to their daughters.
That would be dads like me.....duly forwarding on to all of my friends with daughters as well.
Thank you.
Living in Mexico City taught me to be entirely aware of surroundings. . . even when surrounded by 20 million people.
Just shopping in a store when a fellow-shopper grabbed me and pulled me down to the floor and whispered, "robaje!!" was enough to sober me up. Seeing armed troops outside of banks will make you realize that the desperados play for keeps. Here in the States, where things are getting more desperate: No more mindless boredom in the bank line. Where to dive to if the SHTF. No more pleasant chatter at the checkout of my favorite, friendly grocer's.
I avoid minute markets when possible, am on high alert when pumping gas and lock the door of my vehicle while outside it, lest I be hustled into it too easily.
I have to park in a parking garage now, unfortunately, and that is the worst feeling of all. I'll park on the roof in order to be nearest the door and in the light, but feel all parking scenarios are less than ideal.
My husband decided to walk to work yesterday. A block from home, he witnessed a swift and decisive drug bust right in front of him. No hardware came out, thankfully. You never know.
"A few years ago, there was a talented young woman who was kidnapped by someone she struck up a conversation with her in a national forest, a kindly looking older guy who then went on to terrorize her and kill her. She was young and very strong. She was a Black Belt. It was a sobering revelation."
And also note that having a dog with her did not help either.
I appreciate this post very much, I'd say it's a must read for everybody, especially women. Almost all of it is great advice, except for one piece. DO NOT LAY ON THE GROUND. That's a very foolish move. STAY ON YOUR FEET! If he tries to pick you up, squat down, hard and fast, it makes you hard to pick up. Stomp his feet. Elbow his face, vigorously! Squirm like crazy. If he gets you off the ground, wrap your legs around his to make it hard for him to move, poke his eyes! But for goodness sake, do not lay down. You give away any advantage you have when you do that.
"except for one piece. DO NOT LAY ON THE GROUND. That's a very foolish move."
Please allow me to differ- KidEscape (http://www.kidescape.org/) teaches a wonderfully, simple, effective move...guess what?
When I play fight with our six year old son,
me 5'10" 185#, he 46" 54#, can drop, wrap his arms around my calves, hit the back of my knees and "fall me down". I'm not "letting" him, either.
Thank you, BK, for the Just Yell Fire recommendation.
One of the things that a lot of females do to hobble themselves (literally) is wear foot-gear that they can't run in, and can't use to fight with. If they are not strapped on securely to start with, you might as well wear a sign saying "take me, I'm stupid". Tottering around on 5" heels is not much of an improvement over flip-flops, if any.
Post a Comment